Quotes

"Dialogue is mutual search for a new reality, not debate to win with stronger arguments. In a dialogue propositions are pointers toward a common new reality; not against each other to win a verbal battle, but complementing each other in an effort to accommodate legitimate goals of all parties, inspired by theories and values, and constructive-creative-concrete enough to become a causa finalis". Galtuung


"I use the concept of affect as away of talking about a margin of manouverability, the 'where we might be able to go' and 'what we might be able to do' in every present situation. I guess 'affect' is a word I use for 'hope': Massumi


"A discourse is a system of words, actions, rules, beliefs, and institutions that share common values. Particular discourses sustain particular worldviews. We might even think of a discourse as a worldview in action. Discourses tend to be invisible--taken for granted as part of the fabric of reality."Fairclough


Emergence is “the principle that entities exhibit properties which are meaningful only when attributed to the whole, not to its parts.” Checkland


"What the designer cares about is whether the user perceives that some action is possible (or in the case of perceived non-affordances, not possible)." Norman




Wednesday 28 March 2012

"Getting the wrong end of the 'stick'": on the limitations of language

The 'stick' does not have  an absolute beginning or end unlike the word 'stick'
they are a product of the type of measurement…we know this from 

there is only a 'stick-in-environment; as there is not a ' hand' but a 'hand of body'
this is a limitation of language... (the excluded middle)
the " beginnings" and "ends" of the stick are fictions
created by the measurement system.

Because the 'stick' is situated in an environment
Unlike the abstract version it cannot exist without it's environment


It is not separate from it in an absolute sense.


What are the limits on the application of  binary measurement systems?
e.g. logics based on an excluded middle

If we are insistent on applying a binary classification system to  a continuum
especially if we feel we are identified with one pole in an either or situation
we appear to have no choice but to assign an absolute negative value to the other pole.

This is likely to lead to conflict…

It is the product of a lack of wisdom of how measuring systems (relatively simple designed abstract systems logics) 
relate to  the systems to which they are being applied  i.e. often to  complex living systems

The fact that the things being measured are of the same type, a type both susceptible to measurement makes them an order of magnitude more similar than the 'difference' implied because of the linguistic category applied…?


To move together as a society-in-nature towards sanity we need to understand this...


 the effectiveness of binary measurement in relation to simple physical constructed systems is clear
however in the context of  complexity such as social disputes  it is not enough...

No comments:

Post a Comment